Accessibility Tools

  • Content scaling 100%
  • Font size 100%
  • Line height 100%
  • Letter spacing 100%

April 2011, no. 330

Free Article: No
Contents Category: Fiction
Custom Article Title: Benjamin Chandler reviews 'Chasing Odysseus' by S.D. Gentill
Book 1 Title: Chasing Odysseus
Book Author: S.D. Gentill
Book 1 Biblio: Pantera Press, $19.95 pb, 370 pp, 9780980741865
Book 1 Author Type: Author

S.D. Gentill’s Chasing Odysseus provides a fresh perspective on Homer’s The Odyssey for young readers. It focuses on the adventures of Hero and her three brothers – Machaon, Lycon, and Cadmus – during the fall of Troy and on their subsequent pursuit of Odysseus, king of Ithaca, throughout his legendary voyages. The siblings are raised among the Herdsmen of Ida, who are allied with Troy before and during the siege. After the city falls, the Herdsmen are erroneously labelled as traitors. Only Odysseus knows the truth and can free them from blame; the siblings pursue the Greek hero to win the truth from him.

Gentill’s considered prose mimics the heightened tone of English translations of Homeric verse, which may discourage the targeted Young Adult readership, since it often, almost intentionally, erects a barrier between the reader and the characters or action. For readers of Young Adult fiction who can appreciate the complexity of Gentill’s style, who have at least a passing interest in The Odyssey, or who enjoy Tolkien’s prose, this won’t be a problem.

Gentill doesn’t shy away from the fantasy elements in her work. Though not as present as in the original material, the Greek pantheon is a force in Chasing Odysseus, and the magic Phaeacian vessel in which the young heroes travel is, by the end, almost a character herself.

Chasing Odysseus is at its best when it delves behind the curtain of the original Homeric poem. In allowing minor characters and monsters a voice, Gentill provides a contemporary, sometimes humorous, and not altogether flattering critique of Odysseus’s actions and motivations, as well as a poignant reminder that, in the ancient world, you didn’t have to be a nice person to be a hero; you just had to be the last man left holding a sword.

 

 

CONTENTS: APRIL 2011

Write comment (0 Comments)
Open Page with Judith Beveridge
Free Article: No
Contents Category: Open Page
Custom Article Title: Open Page with Judith Beveridge
Review Article: No
Show Author Link: Yes
Online Only: No
Custom Highlight Text:

I wish we had critics reviewing books who weren’t writers or academics but who were simply passionate readers involved in various walks of life. At present, criticism seems a mixed bag. Some reviewers are terrific, others seem to merely describe rather than come to grips adequately with what they are reviewing.

Display Review Rating: No

Why do you write?

I feel deeply alive when I am being creative, despite the frustrations. I love the challenge of trying to find the right words and turning language into song.

Are you a vivid dreamer?

Some of my dream landscapes have been both the most exquisitely beautiful and the most terrifying places I have ever seen. But mostly my dreams are common anxiety ones about snakes and being naked in public.

Read more: Open Page with Judith Beveridge

Write comment (0 Comments)
Free Article: No
Contents Category: Children's Non-Fiction

Uneven realities

Nigel Pearn

 

The elasticity of fiction, the ‘what if’ – in other words, the genre’s very virtues and interests – are often the characteristics that alienate ‘sensible’ readers. To the literal-minded, literature can present as a self-defeating puzzle. All that pretence is exhausting, irrelevant at best, or, drawing a long line from the Ancient Greeks, morally bankrupt. ‘I don’t read fiction anymore,’ Everyman says (and most often it is a man): ‘thank goodness for non-fiction, for plain speech, for things as they truly are.’

Read more: Nigel Pearn reviews ten non-fiction children's books

Write comment (0 Comments)
Free Article: No
Contents Category: Young Adult Fiction
Custom Article Title: Maya Linden reviews 'Darkwater' by Georgia Blain and 'This Is Shyness' by Leanne Hall
Review Article: Yes
Show Author Link: Yes
Online Only: No
Custom Highlight Text:

Darkness, both literal and symbolic, pervadesthese two recent books. Darkwater, the first Young Adult title by established writer Georgia Blain...

Book 1 Title: Darkwater
Book Author: Georgia Blain
Book 1 Biblio: Random House, $18.95 pb, 278 pp, 9781864719833
Book 1 Author Type: Author
Book 2 Title: This is Shyness
Book 2 Author: Leanne Hall
Book 2 Biblio: Text Publishing, $19.95 pb, 274 pp, 9781921656521
Book 2 Author Type: Author
Display Review Rating: No

Darkness, both literal and symbolic, pervades these two recent books. Darkwater, the first Young Adult title by established writer Georgia Blain (author of four novels, including Closed for Winter, 1998), and a début book, This is Shyness by Leanne Hall, trace the aftermath of events in which brightness gives way to ‘sudden black’ in the lives of teenage characters.

Read more: Maya Linden reviews 'Darkwater' by Georgia Blain and 'This Is Shyness' by Leanne Hall

Write comment (0 Comments)
Free Article: No
Contents Category: Poetry
Custom Article Title: Gig Ryan reviews 'Ashes in the Air' by Ali Alizadeh
Review Article: Yes
Show Author Link: Yes
Online Only: No
Custom Highlight Text:

Poet and novelist Ali Alizadeh’s third book of poetry, Ashes in the Air, reclaims some themes from his earlier poetry collection, Eyes in Times of War (2006). Autobiographical sequences once again interweave with accounts of recent wars and oppression. Alizadeh also explores some ...

Book 1 Title: Ashes in the Air
Book Author: Ali Alizadeh
Book 1 Biblio: University of Queensland Press, $24.95 pb, 94 pp, 9780702238727
Book 1 Author Type: Author
Display Review Rating: No

Poet and novelist Ali Alizadeh’s third book of poetry, Ashes in the Air, reclaims some themes from his earlier poetry collection, Eyes in Times of War (2006). Autobiographical sequences once again interweave with accounts of recent wars and oppression. Alizadeh also explores some conflicting oppositions: neutrality versus partisanship, faith versus scepticism, individualism versus community. Alizadeh travels to the United Arab Emirates, Turkey, and China, and recalls his native Iran, but travel here is both actual and metaphysical. Ashes in the Air commences with ‘Marco Polo’, which hails the birth of his son, and closes with ‘Staph’, an elegy. Poet Louis Armand describes Alizadeh’s work as ‘a poetry ... of what it means for a language to speak truthfully, to witness or to fabricate’, and many poems further illustrate how language shapes and transforms identity. As with other Australian poets such as Ouyang Yu who write in their second language, sameness and difference are presiding concerns in Alizadeh’s work, even humorously so when the carnivorous poet marries a vegetarian. Critically alert to ideas of otherness and its adjoining preconceptions – ‘Speak English! / Say something, camel fucker!’ (‘Sky Burial’) – he questions what identity without language might mean.

Read more: Gig Ryan reviews 'Ashes in the Air' by Ali Alizadeh

Write comment (0 Comments)