Accessibility Tools

  • Content scaling 100%
  • Font size 100%
  • Line height 100%
  • Letter spacing 100%

June 2024, no. 465

The June issue goes subterranean with James Curran on AUKUS and the stark differences between US and Australian rhetoric about the submarine program. Miranda Johnson reports on the erosion of a bicultural consensus in Aotearoa New Zealand. Peter Rose reviews the letters of Shirley Hazzard and Elizabeth Harrower. Matthew Lamb tells of the covert actions involving Frank Moorhouse and a photocopier that strengthened Australia’s copyright laws. James Ley considers Salman Rushdie’s Knife, and Anna Krien a pioneering environmentalist in John Büsst. We review memoirs by Bruce Pascoe and Werner Herzog, and fiction from Shankari Chandran, Louise Milligan, Ceridwen Dovey, and more. And in ABR Arts, Neil Armfield is our guest on Backstage.

Miles Pattenden reviews ‘How the World Made the West: A 4,000-year history’ by Josephine Quinn
Free Article: No
Contents Category: Classics
Review Article: Yes
Show Author Link: Yes
Article Title: Ancient pasts and truths
Article Subtitle: Decolonising Europe's history
Online Only: Yes
Custom Highlight Text:

Decolonising has reached the classics. Complexity, diversity, and entanglement are in. Greece and Rome are, well, out. The movement to ‘reclaim’ Antiquity began with noble aims: to emancipate the ancients from the prism of politics and war through which we like to see them, to emphasise the role of technology and trade in their lives, and to make women and people of colour visible among them again. Alas, decolonisation all too often seems to have descended into ugly arguments over restitution of artefacts (Elgin marbles, anyone?) or the skin shade of this or that Roman notable (Septimius Severus or St Hadrian of Canterbury, for example). Books such as Josephine Quinn’s are the sensible, balancing side of the equation, an antidote to so much virtue signalling and grievance mongering. Quinn’s is an ancient world decentred – provincialised, to invoke Dipesh Chakrabarty’s celebrated term. Greece and Rome remain, but must jostle with others for attention, space, and significance. The argument is simple. Antiquity was far more multipolar, dynamic, and integrated in reality than in the civilisational – and, indeed, civilising – narratives that Europeans since Petrarch have been telling themselves about it.

Featured Image (400px * 250px):
Alt Tag (Featured Image): Miles Pattenden reviews ‘How the World Made the West: A 4,000-year history’ by Josephine Quinn
Book 1 Title: How the World Made the West
Book 1 Subtitle: A 4,000-year history
Book Author: Josephine Quinn
Book 1 Biblio: Bloomsbury, $49.99 hb, 576 pp
Book 1 Author Type: Author
Book 1 Cover Small (400 x 600):
Book 1 Cover (800 x 1200):
Display Review Rating: No

Decolonising has reached the classics. Complexity, diversity, and entanglement are in. Greece and Rome are, well, out. The movement to ‘reclaim’ Antiquity began with noble aims: to emancipate the ancients from the prism of politics and war through which we like to see them, to emphasise the role of technology and trade in their lives, and to make women and people of colour visible among them again. Alas, decolonisation all too often seems to have descended into ugly arguments over restitution of artefacts (Elgin marbles, anyone?) or the skin shade of this or that Roman notable (Septimius Severus or St Hadrian of Canterbury, for example). Books such as Josephine Quinn’s are the sensible, balancing side of the equation, an antidote to so much virtue signalling and grievance mongering. Quinn’s is an ancient world decentred – provincialised, to invoke Dipesh Chakrabarty’s celebrated term. Greece and Rome remain, but must jostle with others for attention, space, and significance. The argument is simple. Antiquity was far more multipolar, dynamic, and integrated in reality than in the civilisational – and, indeed, civilising – narratives that Europeans since Petrarch have been telling themselves about it.

Quinn’s basic conceit is that the reader is best guided through ancient complexity by place. Thus, each chapter opens with a setting: Amarna 1350 bce, Susa 324 bce, ‘between Poitiers and Tours 732’. The aim is laudable, and perhaps a nod to the success of her Worcester College colleague Peter Frankopan, whose well-received The Silk Roads: A new history of the world (2015) travels twenty-five ‘silk roads’. Through her settings, Quinn hopes, like Frankopan, to craft a series of vignettes that reveal connected histories. The effect could be said to wear off somewhat after thirty chapters, for the book does become something of a whistlestop tour through ancient sites, major and minor. But perhaps such fatigue is unavoidable once you withdraw Greco-Roman primacy and are forced to engage pre-modern totality. Quinn starts early (c.2000 bce) and finishes late (Christopher Columbus), which at least leaves plenty of scope to present unknown examples and original insights.

Read more: Miles Pattenden reviews ‘How the World Made the West: A 4,000-year history’ by Josephine Quinn

Write comment (0 Comments)
Open Page with Iain McCalman
Free Article: No
Contents Category: Interview
Custom Article Title: Open Page with Iain McCalman
Review Article: No
Show Author Link: No
Article Title: Open Page with Iain McCalman
Online Only: No
Custom Highlight Text:

Iain McCalman was born in Nyasaland in 1947, and educated in Zimbabwe and Australia. He writes British, European, and Australian histories of popular science, politics, conservation, and literary cultures. His books include The Reef: A passionate history (2013) and Delia Akeley and the Monkey (2022). His new book is John Büsst: Bohemian artist and saviour of reef and rainforest (NewSouth, 2024). He is a former President of the Australian Academy of the Humanities and was Co-Founder and Co-Director of the Sydney [University] Environment Institute (2011-21). He was awarded Officer of the Order of Australia in 2007 for ‘services to history and the humanities’.

Related Article Image (300px * 400px):
Alt Tag (Related Article Image): Open Page with Iain McCalman
Featured Image (400px * 250px):
Alt Tag (Featured Image): Open Page with Iain McCalman
Display Review Rating: No

Iain McCalman  (Lachlan McCalman UNSW Press)Iain McCalman (Lachlan McCalman/UNSW Press)Iain McCalman was born in Nyasaland in 1947, and educated in Zimbabwe and Australia. He writes British, European, and Australian histories of popular science, politics, conservation, and literary cultures. His books include The Reef: A passionate history (2013) and Delia Akeley and the Monkey (2022). His new book is John Büsst: Bohemian artist and saviour of reef and rainforest (NewSouth, 2024). He is a former President of the Australian Academy of the Humanities and was Co-Founder and Co-Director of the Sydney [University] Environment Institute (2011-21). He was awarded Officer of the Order of Australia in 2007 for ‘services to history and the humanities’.


  

If you could go anywhere tomorrow, where would it be and why?

I would dash with my partner, Kate Fullagar, to Sorrento on the Amalfi Coast to repeat a sublime holiday of twenty years ago, drinking Campania wine and eating Caprese salad.

Read more: Open Page with Iain McCalman

Write comment (0 Comments)
Dave Witty reviews ‘Forest Wars: The ugly truth about what’s happening in our tall forests’ by David Lindenmayer
Free Article: No
Contents Category: Environment
Review Article: Yes
Show Author Link: Yes
Article Title: The future of forests
Article Subtitle: A critique of Australian forestry
Online Only: No
Custom Highlight Text:

Shortly after Black Saturday, David Lindenmayer was giving a seminar on post-bushfire recovery when a member of the audience yelled out, ‘If it wasn’t for you greenies, none of this would have happened.’ Lindenmayer’s response was neither defence nor attack, but rather to rephrase the man’s words. ‘Your hypothesis,’ he said, ‘is that a fire in a forest that is logged and regenerated will be less severe than a fire in an intact forest.’ Many years of research followed this heckle. The result? A counter-intuitive finding that fire severity increases in logged forests.

Featured Image (400px * 250px):
Alt Tag (Featured Image): Dave Witty reviews ‘Forest Wars: The ugly truth about what’s happening in our tall forests’ by David Lindenmayer
Book 1 Title: Forest Wars
Book 1 Subtitle: The ugly truth about what's happening in our tall forests
Book Author: David Lindenmayer
Book 1 Biblio: Allen & Unwin, $34.99 pb, 288 pp
Book 1 Author Type: Author
Book 1 Cover Small (400 x 600):
Book 1 Cover (800 x 1200):
Display Review Rating: No

Shortly after Black Saturday, David Lindenmayer was giving a seminar on post-bushfire recovery when a member of the audience yelled out, ‘If it wasn’t for you greenies, none of this would have happened.’ Lindenmayer’s response was neither defence nor attack, but rather to rephrase the man’s words. ‘Your hypothesis,’ he said, ‘is that a fire in a forest that is logged and regenerated will be less severe than a fire in an intact forest.’ Many years of research followed this heckle. The result? A counter-intuitive finding that fire severity increases in logged forests.

This anecdote, recounted in Lindenmayer’s latest book, goes to the heart of his character: a philomath inspired to ask questions; a tireless ecologist who has explored and worked in the same forests for more than forty years. But there is a second Lindenmayer, a more recent creation: an accidental celebrity who has become increasingly outspoken as his detractors have escalated their attacks. It would, as he once said in an interview for the Wonderground journal, be morally irresponsible if he did not communicate what he has learned.

For those researching Lindenmayer online, it can be hard to sift through the rubble of brickbats and sensational headlines and find the scientific work that makes Lindenmayer one of the world’s most oft-cited scientists. For this reason, The Forest Wars is a necessary compendium, a summation of four decades’ worth of research against the backdrop of a rapidly changing industry. Indeed, the timing of this book could not be more opportune. Shortly after Lindenmayer finished the first draft, the Victorian government announced that the cessation of native logging was to be brought forward from 2030 to 2024.

Read more: Dave Witty reviews ‘Forest Wars: The ugly truth about what’s happening in our tall forests’ by...

Write comment (1 Comment)
Anna Krien reviews ‘John Büsst: Bohemian artist and saviour of reef and rainforest’ by Iain McCalman
Free Article: No
Contents Category: Environment
Review Article: Yes
Show Author Link: Yes
Article Title: ‘Good on you, mate!’
Article Subtitle: A fearless and charismatic environmentalist
Online Only: No
Custom Highlight Text:

The ‘Bastard of Bingil Bay’ features on no banknote or coin, nor is he listed in any roll-call of ‘important Australians’, and yet, if it were not for John Büsst, it is likely that twenty-odd national parks and rainforest reserves on the far north-east coast of Queensland would not be so designated and might in fact have been obliterated. It is also probable that, without Büsst, today’s fight for the Great Barrier Reef would have already been lost, the vast ecosystem fragmented into a slew of cement quarries and cheap limestone pits. Considering the extent to which this vast coral labyrinth has shaped the identity of modern Australia, the relative absence of Büsst’s influence from the historical record is doubtless representative of the many such travesties historians seek to rectify.

Featured Image (400px * 250px):
Alt Tag (Featured Image): Anna Krien reviews ‘John Büsst: Bohemian artist and saviour of reef and rainforest’ by Iain McCalman
Book 1 Title: John Büsst
Book 1 Subtitle: Bohemian artist and saviour of reef and rainforest
Book Author: Iain McCalman
Book 1 Biblio: NewSouth, $36.99 pb, 263 pp
Book 1 Author Type: Author
Book 1 Cover Small (400 x 600):
Book 1 Cover (800 x 1200):
Book 1 Readings Link: https://www.readings.com.au/product/9781761170096/john-buesst--iain-mccalman--2024--9781761170096#rac:jokjjzr6ly9m
Display Review Rating: No

The ‘Bastard of Bingil Bay’ features on no banknote or coin, nor is he listed in any roll-call of ‘important Australians’, and yet, if it were not for John Büsst, it is likely that twenty-odd national parks and rainforest reserves on the far north-east coast of Queensland would not be so designated and might in fact have been obliterated. It is also probable that, without Büsst, today’s fight for the Great Barrier Reef would have already been lost, the vast ecosystem fragmented into a slew of cement quarries and cheap limestone pits. Considering the extent to which this vast coral labyrinth has shaped the identity of modern Australia, the relative absence of Büsst’s influence from the historical record is doubtless representative of the many such travesties historians seek to rectify.

It could be said that correcting such omissions is simply part of the job for historians – but for Iain McCalman, one of Australia’s most public-spirited and accomplished humanities scholars, the absence of John Büsst from the pages of Australian history made him uneasy. McCalman, author of The Reef: A passionate history (2013), a fascinating history of the Great Barrier Reef told in twelve tales, had featured Büsst as an important figure alongside Judith Wright and forest ecologist Len Webb in the exhaustive campaign to protect the Reef from being drilled for oil, dredged for fertiliser, and quarried for cement in the 1960s and early 1970s. McCalman named them ‘the poet, the painter and the forester’, and deftly portrayed their friendship as a kind of enlightenment in which the arts and sciences came together, sparking the social movement that led to the Great Barrier Reef marine park. But had he, McCalman worried, emphasised the painter’s role in what was effectively the initiation of environmental policy in this country? Had he conveyed the significance of this incisive, energetic man? After all, hadn’t Wright herself said that Büsst had masterminded the campaign? After one tactical victory, Wright wrote to him: ‘Good on you, mate!’ – adding that their success was ‘All because of YOU.’

Read more: Anna Krien reviews ‘John Büsst: Bohemian artist and saviour of reef and rainforest’ by Iain McCalman

Write comment (0 Comments)
Sam Ryan reviews ‘The Blue Cocktail’ by Audrey Molloy and ‘Ekhō’ by Roslyn Orlando
Free Article: No
Contents Category: Poetry
Review Article: Yes
Show Author Link: Yes
Article Title: What time is it?
Article Subtitle: Two very different collections about identity
Online Only: No
Custom Highlight Text:

Identity is a hard thing to define. What makes us who we are? We have social identities, shaped by our affinities and proximities to social groups, cultural identities informed by values, languages, rituals, traditions, and a whole multitude of different phenomena that combine to make us who we are.

Featured Image (400px * 250px):
Alt Tag (Featured Image): Sam Ryan reviews ‘The Blue Cocktail’ by Audrey Molloy and ‘Ekhō’ by Roslyn Orlando
Book 1 Title: The Blue Cocktail
Book Author: Audrey Molloy
Book 1 Biblio: Pitt Street Poetry, $28 pb, 75 pp
Book 1 Author Type: Author
Book 1 Cover Small (400 x 600):
Book 1 Cover (800 x 1200):
Book 2 Title: Ekhō
Book 2 Author: Roslyn Orlando
Book 2 Biblio: Upswell, $24.99 pb, 75 pp
Book 2 Author Type: Author
Book 2 Cover Small (400 x 600):
Book 2 Cover (800 x 1200):
Display Review Rating: No

Identity is a hard thing to define. What makes us who we are? We have social identities, shaped by our affinities and proximities to social groups, cultural identities informed by values, languages, rituals, traditions, and a whole multitude of different phenomena that combine to make us who we are.

In Roslyn Orlando’s literary début, Ekhō, identity is linked to voice and agency; I am who I am because of what I say and my ability to say it. In Audrey Molloy’s second collection of poetry, The Blue Cocktail, identity is linked to place; I am who I am because of the places I inhabit. Both books have more complex theses and focuses than can be summed up in a few snappy opening paragraphs. For example, Orlando condemns technology as a simple echo of knowledge, and Molloy raises questions of belonging. Identity links these two works and provides a key to understanding their intricacies.

Read more: Sam Ryan reviews ‘The Blue Cocktail’ by Audrey Molloy and ‘Ekhō’ by Roslyn Orlando

Write comment (0 Comments)