Accessibility Tools

  • Content scaling 100%
  • Font size 100%
  • Line height 100%
  • Letter spacing 100%

February 2008, no. 298

Welcome to the February 2008 issue of Australian Book Review!

Free Article: No
Contents Category: Military History
Review Article: Yes
Show Author Link: Yes
Article Title: That most ambiguous of wars
Online Only: No
Custom Highlight Text:

More than thirty years after the last helicopters left the roof of the American embassy in Saigon, the flow of new books on the Vietnam war shows no sign of abating. Among them are some intended for a limited, scholarly market, some for a wider general readership; some for Americans, some for Australians. These three books exemplify some of the trends in both the substance and the style of Vietnam war histories, and illustrate both the virtues and the faults of differing approaches to the most controversial conflict of the twentieth century.

Display Review Rating: No

Vietnam: The Australian war by Paul HamVietnam: The Australian war
                                HarperCollins, $55 hb, 832 pp 

More than thirty years after the last helicopters left the roof of the American embassy in Saigon, the flow of new books on the Vietnam war shows no sign of abating. Among them are some intended for a limited, scholarly market, some for a wider general readership; some for Americans, some for Australians. These three books exemplify some of the trends in both the substance and the style of Vietnam war histories, and illustrate both the virtues and the faults of differing approaches to the most controversial conflict of the twentieth century.

It is not hard to see what the Australian public wants. Stand by the checkout counter of a major bookstore, especially around Anzac Day or during the pre-Christmas rush, and watch the unstoppable advance of thick, square books on Australian military history from the prominent display cases towards Australian living rooms. They usually have evocative, one-word titles like Gallipoli or Kokoda or Tobruk, sometimes with a subtitle that explains that the subject is really the Australian soldier in this or that battle or campaign. Their authors are freelance writers rather than academics, generally with a background in journalism. The outstanding example of the genre is Les Carlyon’s The Great War (2006), co-winner of the inaugural Prime Minister’s Prize for Australian History, but other notable names in the field include Peter FitzSimons, Roland Perry, Paul Ham, and Patrick Lindsay.

To refer to these writers generically as ‘journalists’ is not to deprecate them but simply to contrast them with ‘the professionals’, the military historians in universities and research centres. In military and other forms of history, Australia owes much to a fine tradition of serious journalists, from Charles Bean through Gavin Long and Gavin Souter to Paul Kelly, who have written important and substantial history books.

Read more: Peter Edwards reviews 'Vietnam' by Paul Ham, 'Triumph Forsaken' by Mark Moyar and 'War and Words'...

Write comment (0 Comments)
Brian McFarlane reviews People of the Book by Geraldine Brooks
Free Article: No
Contents Category: Fiction
Review Article: Yes
Show Author Link: Yes
Online Only: No
Custom Highlight Text:

‘I wanted to give a sense of the people of the book, the different hands that had made it, used it, protected it. I wanted it to be a gripping narrative, even suspenseful.’ So says Hanna Heath, protagonist of Geraldine Brooks’s latest novel, about her search through time and place for the history of ‘the Sarajevo Haggadah’, the ‘Book’ of the title ...

Book 1 Title: People of the Book
Book Author: Geraldine Brooks
Book 1 Biblio: HarperCollins, $19.99 pb, 372 pp, 9780007177424
Book 1 Author Type: Author
Display Review Rating: No

‘I wanted to give a sense of the people of the book, the different hands that had made it, used it, protected it. I wanted it to be a gripping narrative, even suspenseful.’ So says Hanna Heath, protagonist of Geraldine Brooks’s latest novel, about her search through time and place for the history of ‘the Sarajevo Haggadah’, the ‘Book’ of the title. She is accustomed to writing scholarly essays that derive from her function as a rare books conservator, full of ‘riveting stuff like how many quires there are and how many leaves per quire… and so on’. She wants this one to be different.

Hanna’s search for the exact provenance of the Haggadah takes her from her home in Sydney, in 1996, to war-ravaged Sarajevo, and thence, having sighted the manuscript, which is ‘small … convenient for use at the Passover dinner table’, to Vienna to see her old mentor Werner Heinrich. She then travels to Boston where, by chance, her mother is also lecturing; then to London, back to Sarajevo; to Sydney via Arnhem Land; and then back to Sarajevo again. The peripatetic requirements of her esoteric profession are tracked through alternating chapters of the novel, which eventually bring her up to 2002.

While Hanna is engaged in travelling halfway round the world in pursuit of her intellectual goals, the alternate chapters chronicle the history of the precious book in reverse chronology. An expert in ancient manuscripts, Serif, and other Jews, including Lola who has lost all her family to the Nazis, join the partisans during World War II, having contrived to save ‘one of the museum’s greatest treasures’, the Haggadah. In successively interleaved chapters, the book’s ownership is traced to Vienna, rife with anti-Semitism in 1894; then to Venice, 1609, where a wealthy Jewess passes the book to a rabbi with a dangerous gambling compulsion and an uneasy friendship with a Catholic priest; to Tarragena, Spain, 1492, when a Jewish diaspora begins; and to Seville, 1480, where Muslim, Catholic and Jewish imprints make themselves felt on the book’s biography. As Hanna comments on this reverse history, we are invited to see the Haggadah at times when it ‘was still just some family’s book, a thing to be used, before it became an exhibit’.

Read more: Brian McFarlane reviews 'People of the Book' by Geraldine Brooks

Write comment (0 Comments)
Ian Donaldson reviews Shakespeare the Thinker by A.D. Nuttall
Free Article: No
Contents Category: Literary Studies
Review Article: Yes
Show Author Link: Yes
Article Title: Learning not to run
Online Only: No
Custom Highlight Text:

Shakespeare the Thinking is the final and posthumously published book of the Oxford critic A.D. Nuttall, who died unexpectedly in January 2007. Pitched at a wider readership than most of his earlier writings, the book is the culmination of Nuttall’s lifetime thinking about Shakespeare, and the work by which his remarkable originality as a critic will no doubt be most widely recognised.

Book 1 Title: Shakespeare the Thinker
Book Author: A.D. Nuttall
Book 1 Biblio: Yale University Press, $59.95 hb, 428 pp
Book 1 Author Type: Author
Display Review Rating: No

Shakespeare the Thinker is the final and posthumously published book of the Oxford critic A.D. Nuttall, who died unexpectedly in January 2007. Pitched at a wider readership than most of his earlier writings, the book is the culmination of Nuttall’s lifetime thinking about Shakespeare, and the work by which his remarkable originality as a critic will no doubt be most widely recognised.

Read more: Ian Donaldson reviews 'Shakespeare the Thinker' by A.D. Nuttall

Write comment (0 Comments)
Peter Pierce reviews A Companion to Australian Literature Since 1900 edited by Nicholas Birns and Rebecca McNeer
Free Article: No
Contents Category: Literary Studies
Review Article: Yes
Show Author Link: Yes
Article Title: Literary stocktaking
Online Only: No
Custom Highlight Text:

When G.B. Barton presented his two works concerning the literary history of New South Wales to the Paris Exhibition of 1866, he hoped that they would enable readers ‘to form an exact idea of the progress, extent and prospects of literary enterprise among us’. The words are succinct, unobjectionable, and their sentiments influenced much of the literary history of the next century, much as the productions of that time were usually annals rather than analysis. Barton’s civic-minded project linked the maturing of Australian literature with its political culture. Implicit in his endeavour, though numerous others would use the metaphor outright, was the notion of ‘coming-of-age’. This chimera had as long a life as the search for the Great Australian Novel.

Book 1 Title: A Companion to Australian Literature Since 1900
Book Author: Nicholas Birns and Rebecca McNeer
Book 1 Biblio: Camden House, £50 hb, 496 pp
Book 1 Author Type: Editor
Display Review Rating: No

When G.B. Barton presented his two works concerning the literary history of New South Wales to the Paris Exhibition of 1866, he hoped that they would enable readers ‘to form an exact idea of the progress, extent and prospects of literary enterprise among us’. The words are succinct, unobjectionable, and their sentiments influenced much of the literary history of the next century, much as the productions of that time were usually annals rather than analysis. Barton’s civic-minded project linked the maturing of Australian literature with its political culture. Implicit in his endeavour, though numerous others would use the metaphor outright, was the notion of ‘coming-of-age’. This chimera had as long a life as the search for the Great Australian Novel.

Read more: Peter Pierce reviews 'A Companion to Australian Literature Since 1900' edited by Nicholas Birns...

Write comment (0 Comments)